Skip to content

Annabelle vs Annabelle Comes Home: which is scarier?

Annabelle is scarier than Annabelle Comes Home: 8.0 against 1.8 out of 10 on the Scare Scale.

  • Annabelle is more suspenseful (6.2 against 4.6).
  • Annabelle messes with your head more (4.5 against 2.9).
  • Annabelle is creepier (6.6 against 5.0).
Annabelle20148.0 /10ScarierAnnabelle Comes Home20191.8 /10

Scare by scare

Gore
Annabelle3.6
Annabelle Comes Home2.9
Creepy
Annabelle6.6
Annabelle Comes Home5.0
Jumpscares
Annabelle5.2
Annabelle Comes Home3.8
Suspense
Annabelle6.2
Annabelle Comes Home4.6
Psychological
Annabelle4.5
Annabelle Comes Home2.9

Seen one of them? Open the film and answer a few quick questions about how it scared you. Every answer moves its score.