Which is scarier, Ice Cream Man or The Long Walk?

Ice Cream Man is scarier than The Long Walk: 6.6 against 3.6 out of 10 on the Scare Scale. Ice Cream Man is gorier (7.0 against 3.0). Ice Cream Man is creepier (6.0 against 2.6). The Long Walk messes with your head more (5.6 against 4.0).

Ice Cream Man vs The Long Walk: which is scarier?

Ice Cream Man is scarier than The Long Walk: 6.6 against 3.6 out of 10 on the Scare Scale.

Ice Cream Man is gorier (7.0 against 3.0).
Ice Cream Man is creepier (6.0 against 2.6).
The Long Walk messes with your head more (5.6 against 4.0).

Ice Cream Man20266.6 /10Scarier

The Long Walk20253.6 /10

Scare by scare

Gore: Ice Cream Man7.0; The Long Walk3.0
Creepy: Ice Cream Man6.0; The Long Walk2.6
Jumpscares: Ice Cream Man4.0; The Long Walk2.6
Suspense: Ice Cream Man5.0; The Long Walk4.3
Psychological: Ice Cream Man4.0; The Long Walk5.6

Seen one of them? Open the film and answer a few quick questions about how it scared you. Every answer moves its score.

Like Ice Cream Man but less scary
Like The Long Walk but less scary