Skip to content
Scare Scale home

Orphan: First Kill vs Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark: which is scarier?

Orphan: First Kill is scarier than Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark: 6.0 against 5.2 out of 10 on the Scare Scale.

  • Orphan: First Kill is more suspenseful (6.0 against 3.2).
  • Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark is gorier (4.6 against 3.0).

Scare by scare

Gore
Orphan: First Kill3.0
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark4.6
Creepy
Orphan: First Kill5.0
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark5.3
Jumpscares
Orphan: First Kill4.0
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark4.6
Suspense
Orphan: First Kill6.0
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark3.2
Psychological
Orphan: First Kill5.0
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark3.9

Seen one of them? Open the film and answer a few quick questions about how it scared you. Every answer moves its score.