Poltergeist vs The Amityville Horror: which is scarier?
The Amityville Horror is scarier than Poltergeist: 5.8 against 5.0 out of 10 on the Scare Scale.
Scare by scare
- Gore
- Poltergeist4.4
- The Amityville Horror3.2
- Creepy
- Poltergeist5.5
- The Amityville Horror6.1
- Jumpscares
- Poltergeist4.6
- The Amityville Horror5.4
- Suspense
- Poltergeist5.0
- The Amityville Horror5.2
- Psychological
- Poltergeist4.2
- The Amityville Horror3.8
Seen one of them? Open the film and answer a few quick questions about how it scared you. Every answer moves its score.


