Score breakdown
How Smile 2 (2024) gets its score of9.4, one rule at a time.
1People's answers become a score for each kind of scare
Each person says how much of each kind of scare the film has, and a few yes/no questions nudge that up or down. Everyone's answers are averaged.
- Gore: 8.8 from 5 people
- Creepy: 6.7 from 6 people
- Jumpscares: 6.4 from 5 people
- Suspense: 6.8 from 5 people
- Psychological: 5.9 from 6 people
2Our estimate fills in until enough people rate it
Every kind of scare starts from Scare Scale's estimate, worked out from similar films. It counts as 2 people at first and less with each rating, until 10 people have rated and only their answers count.
- Gore: estimate 6.8 with people's 8.8 → 8.5
- Creepy: estimate 6.5 with people's 6.7 → 6.6
- Jumpscares: estimate 3.8 with people's 6.4 → 6.0
- Suspense: estimate 5.2 with people's 6.8 → 6.5
- Psychological: estimate 4.9 with people's 5.9 → 5.8
3Scare weighting, then the top three are averaged
Scare weighting compares each kind of scare with other films, lifting what's stronger than usual and lowering what's weaker. The film's score is the average of its three highest.
Kind of scare Rated Scare weighting Score Gore (in the top 3) 8.5 +1.3 9.8 Jumpscares (in the top 3) 6.0 +3.4 9.4 Creepy (in the top 3) 6.6 +2.4 9.0 Suspense 6.5 +2.5 9.0 Psychological 5.8 +2.3 8.1 The highlighted top 3 make up the score:
(9.8 + 9.4 + 9.0) ÷ 3 = 9.4
How scare weighting is worked out
Each kind of scare is compared with every rated film on Scare Scale. The rating that 70% of films come in under becomes a 5, so a 5 means about as strong as most films.
Ratings above that are stretched up towards 10, and ratings below it are pulled down twice as fast towards 0, so only the very strongest films get near 10. The stretch depends on how spread out films are: where most films get similar ratings, small differences count for more.
It's worked out again from the latest ratings whenever the site loads its films, so a film's score can shift a little as other films are rated. Right now:
Kind of scare Becomes 5 at Near 10 from Near 0 below Gore 4.6 7.6 3.1 Creepy 5.2 7.1 4.3 Jumpscares 3.9 6.1 2.8 Suspense 5.3 6.9 4.5 Psychological 4.5 7.1 3.2
All ratings (6)
Anonymous
30 Oct 2026
Creepy 3 · Psychological 2
Their answers
- Creepy
- How creepy was it? A little (3)
- Was the antagonist unconvincing? Yes
- Psychological
- How much did it mess with your head? A bit (3)
- Did the ending just spell everything out for you? Yes (−1)
Anonymous
29 Oct 2026
Gore 10 · Creepy 7 · Jumpscares 10 · Suspense 9 · Psychological 10
Their answers
- Gore
- How much gore was there? A lot (9)
- Was the gore shown close up? Yes (+1)
- Creepy
- How creepy was it? Fairly (6)
- Were there any disturbing images? Yes (+1)
- Jumpscares
- How many jumpscares were there? Lots (9)
- Were there any massive scares that totally caught you off guard? Yes (+1)
- Suspense
- How tense was it? Very (9)
- Was the whole plot predictable? No
- Psychological
- How much did it mess with your head? A lot (9)
- Did it stay on your mind afterwards? Yes (+1)
Anonymous
26 Oct 2026
Gore 7 · Creepy 0 · Jumpscares 5 · Suspense 0 · Psychological 0
Their answers
- Gore
- How much gore was there? Quite a bit (6)
- Was the gore shown close up? Yes (+1)
- Creepy
- How creepy was it? Not at all (0)
- Jumpscares
- How many jumpscares were there? Several (6)
- Were the majority of the jumpscares anticlimactic? Yes (−1)
- Suspense
- How tense was it? Not at all (0)
- Psychological
- How much did it mess with your head? Not at all (0)
Anonymous
18 Oct 2026
Gore 10 · Creepy 10 · Jumpscares 2 · Suspense 8 · Psychological 3
Their answers
- Gore
- How much gore was there? A lot (9)
- Was any of it hard to watch? Yes (+1)
- Creepy
- How creepy was it? Very (9)
- Were you still spooked afterwards? Yes (+1)
- Jumpscares
- How many jumpscares were there? A few (3)
- Were the majority of the jumpscares anticlimactic? Yes (−1)
- Suspense
- How tense was it? Very (9)
- Did it feel like nothing was happening for long periods of time? Yes (−1)
- Psychological
- How much did it mess with your head? A bit (3)
- Did the ending just spell everything out for you? No
Anonymous
14 Oct 2026
Gore 8 · Creepy 8 · Jumpscares 7 · Suspense 9 · Psychological 10
Their answers
- Gore
- Rating before the scare questions 8 out of 10
- Creepy
- Rating before the scare questions 8 out of 10
- Jumpscares
- Rating before the scare questions 7 out of 10
- Suspense
- Rating before the scare questions 9 out of 10
- Psychological
- Rating before the scare questions 10 out of 10
gruselhurz
3 Oct 2026
Gore 6 · Creepy 8 · Jumpscares 7 · Suspense 9 · Psychological 9
Their answers
- Gore
- Rating before the scare questions 6 out of 10
- Creepy
- Rating before the scare questions 8 out of 10
- Jumpscares
- Rating before the scare questions 7 out of 10
- Suspense
- Rating before the scare questions 9 out of 10
- Psychological
- Rating before the scare questions 9 out of 10