Jaws 2
1978
3.6/10
Films like You Should Have Left, but less scary
You Should Have Left scores 4.8 out of 10 on the Scare Scale. These films scare in a similar way (the same series, studio or kind of fear) and are each at least a point gentler.
Virus
1999
3.4/10
They/Them
2022
3.5/10
The Black Phone
2022
2.8/10
The Funhouse
1981
3.8/10
The Wolfman
2010
2.9/10
Child's Play 3
1991
2.7/10
Cat People
1982
3.7/10
Child's Play 2
1990
3.0/10
Halloween
2018
2.8/10
Jaws: The Revenge
1987
2.3/10
Truth or Dare
2018
3.7/10
Or, if it wasn't scary enough
The Exorcist: Believer
2023
6.1/10
The Unborn
2009
6.3/10
The Forever Purge
2021
6.0/10
Phantasm II
1988
6.3/10
Raising Cain
1992
6.4/10
Imaginary
2024
6.3/10