Skip to content
Poster for Return to Silent Hill

Return to Silent Hill

4.5 out of 10

Stream it
Trailer on TMDB

When James receives a mysterious letter from his lost love Mary, he is drawn to Silent Hill—a once-familiar town now consumed by darkness. As he searches for her, James faces monstrous creatures and unravels a terrifying truth that will push him to the edge of his sanity.

Rate it: how scary was Return to Silent Hill?

How scary is Return to Silent Hill?

Return to Silent Hill parents guide

Each kind of scare rated out of 10, with what to expect. Use the info button for the full scale.

  • Gore

    3.4 out of 10,Moderate

    Visible blood and wounds in a few scenes

  • Creepy

    5.6 out of 10,Strong

    Disturbing images and an atmosphere that feels wrong

  • Jumpscares

    3.5 out of 10,Moderate

    A handful of jumpscares that land

  • Suspense

    5.1 out of 10,Strong

    High tension that keeps you on edge

  • Psychological

    5.0 out of 10,Strong

    Paranoia, madness or a story that makes you question what's real

How the overall score of 4.5 is worked out

Scare weighting compares each kind of scare with other films, lifting what's stronger than usual and lowering what's weaker, so only the strongest get near 10. The Scare Scale score is the average of the three highest.

Kind of scareRatedScare weightingScore
Psychological (in the top 3)5.0+1.56.5
Creepy (in the top 3)5.6−0.25.4
Jumpscares (in the top 3)3.5−2.01.5
Suspense5.1−4.11.0
Gore3.4−3.10.3

The highlighted top 3 make up the score:

(6.5 + 5.4 + 1.5) ÷ 3 = 4.5

See the full breakdown and every rating

Comments

Add comment
Loading comments…

Where it sits on the Scare Scale

Every line is a rated film. Hover, tap or drag along the line to compare.

Films ranked either side
  1. Trailer Park of Terror4.5
  2. Return to Silent Hill (this film)4.5
  3. Ghost Shark4.5

Horror films like Return to Silent Hill

All movies like Return to Silent Hill, ranked by how scary they are

See the full lists: Silent Hill Collectionsurvival horror filmshorror films for beginners

Return to Silent Hill questions

How scary is Return to Silent Hill?

On a scale of 1 to 10, Return to Silent Hill scores 4.5 for how scary it is. Strong creepiness and strong suspense. That makes it the 2133rd scariest of 3960 films rated on Scare Scale.

Does Return to Silent Hill have jump scares?

Yes. Its jumpscares are moderate: a handful of jumpscares that land.

How gory is Return to Silent Hill?

Its gore is moderate: visible blood and wounds in a few scenes.

Where can I watch Return to Silent Hill?

It's streaming on Hulu, Screambox and Cineverse in the US, Amazon Prime Video in the UK, Crave and Hoopla in Canada and Amazon Prime Video, Paramount Plus and Foxtel Now in Australia. The page shows the services in your own country.

Social images

Download the score as an image, sized for each kind of post.